Price against profit
Back to lesson 1: Cedar & Crumb Bakery earned $0.30 of profit per share. If one share costs $6:
P/E = $6 ÷ $0.30 = 20
You are paying $20 for every $1 of last year's profit. Another way to say it: if profits never grew, it would take 20 years of profit to equal the price you paid. Flip it over and you get the earnings yield: $0.30 ÷ $6 = 5% a year.
Same business, same $0.30 of profit per share. Only the price changes. Invented numbers.
None of these is "right". A P/E of 40 can be reasonable for a company whose profits really do grow fast for years. It is a problem when that growth doesn't arrive. The useful question is: what does this price assume, and how likely is that?
Limits of the P/E: it means nothing when profits are negative, one strange year can distort it, and it ignores debt. That's why lessons 3 and 4 come first.
Why most people still own the whole market
Reading businesses is a useful skill. Beating the market by picking them is a much harder one. Over the 10 years to the end of 2025, S&P's SPIVA Canada report found that 98.8% of Canadian equity funds trailed the S&P/TSX Composite. Those are full-time professionals with research teams.
That's why Planted North keeps a No-Picks Pledge. Learning to read a business makes you a better owner of an index fund: you know what's inside, you understand why prices move, and you're harder to fool.
Red flags: research or a sales pitch?
In April 2026, Canada's securities regulators warned about a surge in "ramp-and-dump" scams: groups on social media and private chat apps that pile into a low-priced, thinly traded stock, push the price up, then sell to the people they recruited. Watch for:
- An invitation to a WhatsApp or Telegram "investment group" from someone you met online.
- Urgency: "buy before Monday", "last chance".
- Promised or "guaranteed" returns.
- Talk about the price, never about the business's filings, margins or cash.
- A person or firm offering advice who isn't registered. Check on the CSA's National Registration Search.
The questions from this path are your defence. How does it make money? Does that turn into cash? What does the price assume? A tip that can't answer them isn't research.
Do this before the next lesson
- For the company you picked, find this year's share price and its earnings per share (on the income statement, near the bottom).
- Work out the P/E and the earnings yield. Don't act on it: just write both down.
- Write one line: "This price assumes profits will ___." Then check whether the MD&A sounds that confident.
Two companies earn $2 of profit per share. One trades at $20, the other at $60. What does the higher price tell you?
Was this lesson clear?
Something confusing, missing or wrong? Email Lucas. Every message gets read.
Your progress is saved on this device only. No account needed.
One idea, one move, one number. Five minutes. No picks, ever. Join free and get the 64-page Field Guide.
Where this comes from
- Morningstar Canada: Starting out in stocks, the price-to-earnings ratio
- S&P Dow Jones Indices: SPIVA Canada Year-End 2025 (Canadian Equity funds vs S&P/TSX Composite, 10 years: 98.82% underperformed)
- Ontario Securities Commission: CSA Investor Alert on ramp-and-dump scams (April 2026)
- Canadian Securities Administrators: National Registration Search ("Are they registered?")
- Cedar & Crumb Bakery and all of its numbers are invented to teach the ideas. It is not a real company.