Planted North
The short versionWe value today much more than later, so "I'll start next month" keeps moving. The fix that works best in the research is not more willpower but a default: money that moves on its own after payday. When one company made saving automatic, participation jumped from 37% to 86%.

"Next month" is a moving target

Present bias is our tendency to give today far more weight than any future day. Saving $100 next month sounds easy. Saving $100 today feels like a sacrifice. When next month arrives, it becomes today, and the same thing happens again.

Thaler and Benartzi cite a survey of people who said they were saving too little. About a third planned to save more in the next few months. Four months later, 86% of those had changed nothing.

What happened when saving became the default

In 2001, economists Brigitte Madrian and Dennis Shea studied a large U.S. company that changed one thing: new employees were enrolled in the retirement plan automatically, and could leave if they wanted.

Share of new employees saving in the plan
Had to sign up37%
Joined by default86%

Same people, same plan, same choices. Only the default changed. Source: Madrian and Shea (2001), as summarized by the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.

Another program, Save More Tomorrow, asked people to commit now to raising their savings rate at each future raise. 78% of those offered it joined, and their average savings rate rose from 3.5% to 13.6% of pay in about 40 months. Asking for the increase later, out of money they didn't have yet, got around present bias.

Build your own default

  • Pay yourself first. Set an automatic transfer from chequing to your TFSA, FHSA or RRSP for the day after payday, before you can spend it. Most Canadian banks and brokers call this a pre-authorized contribution or recurring deposit.
  • Automate the investing too, if your account allows it, so the deposit doesn't sit as cash.
  • Save more tomorrow. Decide now: every time your pay goes up, the automatic amount goes up by part of the raise.
  • Use your employer's plan if it matches contributions. A match is part of your pay.

The pay-yourself-first planner turns your paycheque into two or three automatic transfers, in about two minutes.

Your move · 10 minutes

Do this before the next lesson

  1. Open the pay-yourself-first planner and pick an amount you won't miss.
  2. Set the automatic transfer for the day after payday, today.
  3. Put a yearly reminder in your calendar: "raise my automatic deposit".
Quick check

According to the research in this lesson, what made the biggest difference to whether people saved?

Beta · help shape this

Was this lesson clear?

Something confusing, missing or wrong? Email Lucas. Every message gets read.

Your progress is saved on this device only. No account needed.

One lesson like this, every Sunday

One idea, one move, one number. Five minutes. No picks, ever. Join free and get the 64-page Field Guide.

Join free
Sources

Where this comes from