Planted North
The short versionMost of us think we are better than average at things we care about, including investing. In a classic study of 66,465 households, the fifth who traded the most earned 11.4% a year after costs while the market earned 17.9%. The gap came from the trading itself. A decision journal is the simplest antidote.

The households that traded the most

Economists Brad Barber and Terrance Odean studied 66,465 U.S. households with accounts at a discount broker from 1991 to 1996. The average household turned over about 75% of its stock portfolio each year.

Yearly return after trading costs, 1991–1996
Traded least18.5%
Market index17.9%
Average household16.4%
Traded most11.4%

Before costs, the heavy traders picked stocks about as well as everyone else. The costs of trading so often did the damage. Source: Barber and Odean (2000).

Trading is cheaper today, and many Canadian brokers charge $0 commissions. But the bid-ask spread, currency conversion, taxes in non-registered accounts and, most of all, bad timing still cost money. Cheap trades make it easier to trade too much.

Why we stay so sure

Confirmation bias is our habit of noticing what agrees with us and scrolling past what doesn't. The Ontario Securities Commission calls it one of the most deeply rooted biases. Once you own something, every good headline about it feels like proof and every bad one feels like noise.

Two more signs of overconfidence: crediting wins to skill and losses to bad luck, and putting a large share of your money in one idea you're "sure" about.

The decision journal

Before any trade you didn't plan, write down
  1. What I'm doing and why, in one sentence.
  2. The best argument against it (look it up on purpose).
  3. What would prove me wrong, and what I'll do then.
  4. The date. Reread it in a year.

A journal doesn't stop you from acting. It keeps an honest record, so next year you learn from what you actually thought, not what you remember thinking.

Your move · 10 minutes

Do this before the next lesson

  1. Count your trades from the last 12 months (your broker's activity page shows them). Was each one part of a plan?
  2. Start a decision journal: a note on your phone with the four questions above.
  3. For one investment you're sure about, search for the strongest case against it and read it to the end.
Quick check

In the Barber and Odean study, why did the households that traded most earn the least?

Beta · help shape this

Was this lesson clear?

Something confusing, missing or wrong? Email Lucas. Every message gets read.

Your progress is saved on this device only. No account needed.

One lesson like this, every Sunday

One idea, one move, one number. Five minutes. No picks, ever. Join free and get the 64-page Field Guide.

Join free
Sources

Where this comes from