Planted North
The short versionMost people feel a loss roughly twice as strongly as a gain of the same size. That made sense for our ancestors, but it pushes investors to sell in a drop and to check their balance far too often. The fix is mostly about distance: check less, and judge a holding by today, not by what you paid.

Losses loom larger

In 1979, psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky showed that people judge outcomes as gains or losses from a starting point, and that losses weigh more. In 1992 they put a number on it: in their experiments, a loss counted about 2.25 times as much as an equal gain.

That first estimate came from 25 graduate students. In 2024, a review of 607 estimates from 150 studies landed close to it: on average, about 2 to 1. It varies by person and by situation, but it is real and it is common.

Try it on yourself

A coin flip. Heads, you win $150. Tails, you lose $100. On average this bet pays you $25 a flip. Would you take it?

Many people say no. With losses counting about twice as much, the $100 loss "feels like" $200, which is more than the $150 win. Nothing about the bet changed. Only how it feels.

Checking often makes it worse

Stocks go up over long periods, but on any single day they fall often. Look every day and you see a lot of red, and each red day stings more than a green day pleases. In 1995, economists Shlomo Benartzi and Richard Thaler called this myopic loss aversion: loss aversion plus looking too often. In a 1997 experiment, people who saw their results more often chose to take less risk than people who saw the same results less often.

Your long-term money doesn't need daily attention. Your nervous system will thank you for a calmer schedule.

The "get back to even" trap

When something is down from what you paid, it is tempting to hold until it "gets back to even" before you sell, and to sell winners early to lock in the good feeling. But the price you paid is history. The market doesn't know it, and it doesn't make a recovery more likely.

A better question: "If I had this money in cash today, would I buy this, at this price, for this goal?" If yes, keep it. If no, the purchase price is not a reason to stay.

In a taxable (non-registered) account, selling can trigger capital gains tax or a deductible loss, and buying it back within 30 days can deny the loss. See the taxable accounts lesson. Inside a TFSA or RRSP, there is no tax on the sale.

Your move · 10 minutes

Do this before the next lesson

  1. Pick a checking schedule for your long-term investments: once a month or once a quarter. Put it in your calendar.
  2. Move your investing app off your phone's home screen.
  3. For any holding that is down, answer the question above in one sentence: would you buy it today?
Quick check

You bought a fund at $20. It is now $15. Which question helps you decide best?

Beta · help shape this

Was this lesson clear?

Something confusing, missing or wrong? Email Lucas. Every message gets read.

Your progress is saved on this device only. No account needed.

One lesson like this, every Sunday

One idea, one move, one number. Five minutes. No picks, ever. Join free and get the 64-page Field Guide.

Join free
Sources

Where this comes from